Tone library / Metallica / Sad But True

Sad But True amp settings — Blackstar HT5R MkII

The Metallica guitar tone for “Sad But True”, dialed in for a Blackstar HT5R MkII with a Fender American Professional II Stratocaster. Studio version, Metallica (The Black Album, 1991) - Main Riff

Original rig

ESP MX-220 (EMG 81/60) into Mesa Boogie Mark IIC++ and Jose-modded Marshall, Marshall 1960 4x12 cab with V30s, Aphex EQF-2 (1.2kHz mid-cut), Aphex CX-1 Compressor in loop. D Standard tuning.

Massive, tight, down-tuned metal chug — heavy low-end thump with scooped mids and controlled high-gain saturation
Amp settings — Blackstar HT5R MkII
CHANNELOverdrive (Voice 2 / Modern) - ISF set to 4 (American/Mesa bias)BOOSToff
GAIN 7 BASS 8 MID 3 TREBLE 7 REVERB 1 MASTER 6
KnobSetting (0–10)
Gain7
Bass8
Mid3
Treble7
Reverb1
Master6
Don’t have a Blackstar HT5R MkII? See this song on other amps → Match your own rig →
Guitar
PICKUPbridge TONE8 VOLUME10
Signal chain

01Boss DS-1 Distortion

Used as a tight front-end boost to compress and focus the single-coil attack into the amp's high-gain channel.

Tone 4 · Level 8 · Dist 1
Why these settings

The HT-5R MkII lacks a dedicated presence control, so treble is pushed to 7 while the ISF is dialed toward American (around 4) to emulate the Mark IIC+ classic 'V' mid-scoop. Because your Stratocaster single coils are inherently thinner and brighter than Hetfield's active humbuckers, bass is raised to 8, tone is rolled back to 8, and the DS-1 is engaged with minimal distortion and high output to tighten the low-end without adding mud. Ensure your guitar is tuned down a full step to D Standard (D-G-C-F-A-D) to match the heavy string tension and low fundamental of the recording.

PRO TIPUse heavy palm-muting right against the bridge saddles with forceful, downstroke-only picking to replicate James Hetfield's signature percussive attack.

Get this tone on your amp

These settings are for a Blackstar HT5R MkII. ToneAdapt matches any song to whatever amp, guitar and pedals you own — first match is free.

Get ToneAdapt on Google Play
More tones for the Blackstar HT5R MkII
IronmanBlack sabathAngleAerosmithSeek and destroyMetálicaParanoidBlack SabbathMaster of PuppetsMetallicaUnholy ConfessionsAvenged Sevenfold
Find your amp
Browse
Blackstar HT5R MkII settingsALL SONGS FOR THIS AMP Sad But True on other ampsSAME SONG, YOUR AMP Metallica tonesALL SONGS Metallica on the Blackstar HT5R MkIISAME ARTIST, SAME AMP Fender American Professional II Stratocaster tonesSAME GUITAR Tone libraryEVERYTHING

Song, artist and gear names are used to identify the tone being matched; ToneAdapt is not affiliated with or endorsed by the artists or manufacturers mentioned. Settings are AI-generated starting points — trust your ears.

Get ToneAdapt — first match free